Stouffville has made national news in the past few weeks, as the local peace churches have strongly opposed plans to celebrate the War of 1812. (lots of coverage by CBC's As it Happens)
Watching from afar, I've been admiring this bold witness to peace my brothers and sisters are making, especially with the whole country watching.
It's a little tempting to use the Stouffville actions as a model for faithful witness today, given the huge attention given to this community. These are the bold peacemakers for Christ!
Yet, I know there have been many other faithful witnesses to peace in our history, and yes, today as well.
An equally faithful group of peace witnesses have been raising questions about how the War of 1812 is celebrated down in Niagara. Their commitment has led to inspiring engagements like this blog, and an 1812 bike tour to conscientious objector sites.
For the most part, the Niagara peace churches have not made the news. Stouffville peace churches have. The difference?
Conflict.
The Niagara churches have tried to offer an alternative voice to the 1812 conversation in Niagara. I think they've done that rather well.
The Stouffville churches, on the other hand, directly opposed specific plans by specific people. Conflict created. And where there's conflict, there's media.
This is not to suggest that we peacemakers should constantly seek out the attention of the media.
But the media is an important tool in grassroots peacemaking and forming public opinion. More people talking about war, militarism and peace can only be a good thing.
Maybe it's time the peace churches start picking more fights in order to create peace???
Showing posts with label peace churches. Show all posts
Showing posts with label peace churches. Show all posts
Thursday, 7 June 2012
Monday, 27 February 2012
MENNONITE AND BiC HISTORICAL ACTORS WANTED!
A new
documentary about the ravages of the War of 1812 in south-western Ontario is being developed. It will include the 1813
battle at Moraviantown (near Chatham), where so many Mennonites and
Brethren in Christ suffered great losses. They had been helping with the
retreat of supplies and refugees (technically: internally displaced persons) from the fortified locations near Detroit..
This is a key element of my ongoing research, in which I'm trying to determine the nature and extent of Mennonite and Brethren in Christ involvement in this transport operation. The film looks at the ugly devastation of war and also the inglorious acts of treason that were committed by many Canadian residents at that time, who seemed prepared to see victory go to the Americans.
This is a key element of my ongoing research, in which I'm trying to determine the nature and extent of Mennonite and Brethren in Christ involvement in this transport operation. The film looks at the ugly devastation of war and also the inglorious acts of treason that were committed by many Canadian residents at that time, who seemed prepared to see victory go to the Americans.
By the way, they're still looking for
actors, horses and wagons. Preferably, although not necessarily, the
actors might also be horse-riding and wagoneering Mennonites and
Brethren in Christ!?
Monday, 20 February 2012
War of 1812: Stupid? Maybe. Important? Yes.
by Carol Penner
I’ve
borrowed my title from an article in the Globe and Mail by Jeremy Diamond and
Davida Aronovitch (20/02/12). The article uses recent polls to contrast the
attitudes in the United States and Canada about war, history and patriotism.
The authors speak disparagingly about celebrating a brutal conflict. Instead
they ask for an investigation into a historical event: what did it mean?
As a Mennonite Christian, I resonate
with this. I’ve been very uncomfortable with any mention of celebration about
the War of 1812, and since I live in Niagara, I’ve seen that word a lot in the
past months. Two hundred years may sanitize the battlefields for most people,
but the cost in human suffering was real on both sides.
I hope that the coming years will
allow us to look at the significance of not just this war, but all wars. “War with
the United States” rings so falsely now, since we are major allies; who knows
whether in 200 years “War with Afghanistan” might also ring falsely.
Monday, 16 January 2012
The bicentennial year is here!!!
by Jonathan Seiling
So many people have been undertaking projects and preparations leading up to this year so let the fanfare begin....
So many people have been undertaking projects and preparations leading up to this year so let the fanfare begin....
Currently there are web pages on the Mennonite Central Committee
Ontario website on this topic. They
commemorate experience of the historic peace churches in Upper Canada,
including Quakers, Brethren in Christ and Mennonites (otherwise known historically
as the "Society of Friends", the "Tunkers" and
"Menonists" in case you're looking for some oddly-spelled proper
nouns for your next Scrabble match that accepts standard English words not in the dictionary!)
Visit the
site and you’ll find: 1) an events calendar; 2) the texts and some photos of historic
markers in Niagara (with translations into French); 3) a link back to this
blog! 4) other materials to be added soon.
The historic markers can be visited in reality and, thanks to the
MCCO website, they can be visited in virtual reality.
A forum in war-full times
by Carol Penner
Two hundred years ago, in 1812, groups of Christians in the Niagara Peninsula and other parts of Upper Canada, refused to participate in the hostilities between the British and the Americans. These Christians, from three denominations, (now known as) the Quakers, the Brethren in Christ, and the Mennonites, all sought conscientious objector status from the government. They had been promised this option when they first arrived in Canada as immigrants.
Two hundred years ago, in 1812, groups of Christians in the Niagara Peninsula and other parts of Upper Canada, refused to participate in the hostilities between the British and the Americans. These Christians, from three denominations, (now known as) the Quakers, the Brethren in Christ, and the Mennonites, all sought conscientious objector status from the government. They had been promised this option when they first arrived in Canada as immigrants.
What was it
like to be peaceful in a world at war? What did that position cost them, in
terms of their standing in the community? Were there dissenting voices even
among these peace churches? How did being peaceful Christians in war-full times
play out in the lives of women and men of that time?
As Canada and
the United States begin to commemorate the War of 1812, how do we as modern-day
peacemakers respond? How are our beliefs the same or different? What is our relationship to our governments
in this current war-full time? There are so many questions: we hope this blog
will be a place of lively discussion and dialogue.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
